| Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools. |
Effects of Fluoride on the Interactions between Amelogenin and Apatite Crystals
1 Department of Orofacial Sciences, University of California, San Francisco, 513 Parnasuss Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94143, USA; Correspondence: * corresponding author, Pamela.denbesten{at}ucsf.edu
Fluorosed enamel is more porous and less mineralized, possibly related to altered amelogenin-modulated crystal growth. The purpose of this study was to examine the role of fluoride in interactions between amelogenin and apatite crystals. Recombinant human amelogenin (rh174) was bound to carbonated hydroxyapatite containing various amounts of fluoride, and analyzed by protein assay, SDS PAGE, and AFM. Interactions between rh174 and fluoride were assayed by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). The initial binding rate of rh174, as well as total amount of rh174 bound to fluoride-containing carbonated hydroxyapatite, was greater than that in the control carbonated hydroxyapatite. Fluoride in solution at physiologic (5.3 micromolar, or 0.1 ppm) concentrations showed no significant effect on binding, but higher fluoride levels significantly decreased protein binding. ITC showed no interactions between fluoride and rh174. These results suggest that fluoride incorporation into the crystal lattice alters the crystal surface to enhance amelogenin binding, with no direct interactions between fluoride and amelogenin.
Key Words: amelogenin hydroxyapatite fluoride enamel fluorosis
Fluoride participates in various aspects of enamel formation and has substantial effects on the properties of the enamel crystals, even at relatively low (micromolar in plasma) concentrations (DenBesten et al., 2002; Robinson et al., 2004). Excess intake of fluoride during enamel development causes enamel defects, which become more severe with increasing fluoride intake and exposure time (DenBesten, 1999; Aoba and Fejerskov, 2002). The mechanisms by which fluoride affects enamel formation to result in fluorosis are not fully understood. However, effects of fluoride on mineralization of the enamel matrix, resulting in enhanced adsorption of matrix proteins to growing crystals, have been proposed (Aoba et al., 1990; Robinson and Kirkham, 1990). The enamel matrix is secreted by epithelial-derived ameloblasts, as a protein matrix that self-assembles to promote mineral growth (Sasaki and Shimokawa, 1979; Fincham et al., 1995; Fincham and Simmer, 1997; Paine and Snead, 2005). Amelogenin, which is the dominant protein in the developing enamel matrix, plays an essential role in the control and modulation of enamel crystal growth (Fincham et al., 1999; Gibson et al., 2001). When amelogenin binds to crystal surfaces, it inhibits apatite crystal growth (Aoba and Moreno, 1987). Presumably, controlled hydrolysis of amelogenins by the proteinases in the enamel matrix, including MMP-20 and KLK-4 (Hu et al., 2002), results in directed growth of the enamel matrix crystals. Any disruption of this process is likely to alter enamel formation. The question that we sought to address in this study is whether fluoride can alter the surface properties of apatites, similar to those found in tooth enamel, to affect amelogenin binding to the apatites. Changes in amelogenin binding to apatites could contribute to the formation of fluorosed enamel.
Synthesis and Characterization of Apatites Hydroxyapatite, carbonated hydroxyapatite, and fluoride-containing carbonated apatites were synthesized as previously described (Featherstone et al., 1983; Ellies et al., 1988), and characterized by x-ray diffraction and FTIR (see APPENDIX for details). The specific surface areas of the apatite particles were measured by the Brunauer-Emmet-Teller (BET) method with a Micrometrics TriStar 3000 (Micrometrics Instrument Corp., Norcross, GA, USA). The surface areas for the various synthetic apatites were similar, ranging between 72 and 80 m2/g. The fluoride concentrations of the apatite particles were measured by means of an ion specific electrode, following diffusion into an alkaline trap (Zero et al., 1992). Fluoride-containing carbonated apatites that we synthesized contained either 98, 943, or 2021 ppm fluoride.
Synthesis of Recombinant Human Amelogenin (rh174)
Effects of Fluoride Substitution in Apatite on rh174 Binding to Apatites To determine the effect of fluoride in apatite on the total protein bound to the apatite, we washed hydroxyapatite, carbonated hydroxyapatite, and fluoride-containing hydroxyapatites (98 and 2021 ppm F–) (0.5 mg each separately), and equilibrated them in 20 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, in 1.7-mL siliconized tubes (Corning, Corning, NY, USA). Different amounts of rh174 (20, 35, 50, 65, 80, 95, and 110 µg) were incubated with the washed apatite crystals on a shaking incubator for 60 min at 25°C. The samples were centrifuged, and the pellets were collected, washed with 20 mM Tris buffer, and dissolved in 50 µL of 1.0% formic acid, neutralized by 1.5 M Tris-HCl, pH 8.8. The bound protein was visualized by SDS PAGE and quantified by the Bradford assay (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA). The value was calibrated to the specific surface area of each form of apatite (m2/g).
Effects of Fluoride and Calcium in Solution on rh174 Binding to Apatites
Effect of Fluoride Pre-treatment of Apatite Crystals on rh174 Binding
Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) Observation of Amelogenin Bound to a Fluorapatite Surface
Interactions between Amelogenin and Fluoride, Detected by Isothermal Titration Calorimetery (ITC)
Statistical Analysis
Fluoride Substitutions in Apatite Crystal Lattice Increased rh174 Binding. The initial rate of rh174 binding to fluoride-containing hydroxyapatite was greater than that to carbonated hydroxyapatite (Figs. 1A, 1B
Fluoride Effects on rh174 Binding to Apatite Crystals were Reduced with Increased Fluoride in Solution. The addition of a physiological concentration of F– (0.1 ppm) to the assay buffer did not affect the binding of rh174 to carbonated hydroxyapatite and fluoride-containing hydroxyapatite (Fig. 2A
Pre-treatment of the apatite with 2000 ppm NaF resulted in significant decreases (30.2 and 42.8%) of rh174 binding on carbonated hydroxyapatite and fluoride-containing carbonated hydroxapatite (98 ppm F–) (Fig. 3
The AFM observation on fluorapatite ceramic disks showed that the (001) face of the typical hexagonal fluorapatite crystal (Fig. 4A
rh174 binding was not affected by pre-treatment of apatite with the divalent ions, Ca+2 or Mg+2 (APPENDIX).
Fluoride Binding to rh174 Detected by ITC
In these studies, we first sought to determine whether fluoride incorporation into carbonated hydroxyapatites could alter amelogenin binding to apatite. Second, we sought to improve our understanding of the nature of amelogenin/apatite interaction by examining the effects of fluoride ions in solution on protein binding. For these studies, we synthesized carbonated apatites, shown to be similar to the 3–5% carbonated hydroxyapatites found in dental enamel (Nelson and Featherstone, 1982). The fluoride levels chosen for these fluoride-containing carbonated hydroxyapatites were based on fluoride levels in human fluorosed enamel (Richards et al., 1989). The amount of fluoride in the lower-fluoride-containing apatite (approximately 100 ppm F–) is similar to that found in the inner enamel (300 µm from the surface) of human teeth with minimal fluorosis. The amount in the higher-fluoride-containing apatite (approximately 2000 ppm F–) is similar to that found in the mid-layer of enamel (150 µm from the surface) in severely fluorosed teeth. We found that carbonate did not affect amelogenin binding to apatite, suggesting that while carbonate is known to destabilize the crystal lattice (LeGeros and Tung, 1983), the substitution of approximately 3% (overall w/w) carbonate in place of the phosphate ions does not significantly affect the affinity of amelogenin for mineral. However, increased fluoride incorporation into the crystalline lattice resulted in increased amelogenin binding to the apatite crystals. These results support those from a previous study by Tanabe and co-workers (Tanabe et al., 1988), who found that commercially available fluorapatites with increasing levels of fluoride substitutions had increased binding of porcine enamel matrix proteins. There are several possible explanations for this effect of fluoride. The first, as described by Tanabe and co-workers (Tanabe et al., 1988) is that the fluoride-containing apatite crystal lattice has higher stability, which implies a lower free energy on crystal surfaces. Protein adsorption on the crystal surfaces would then displace more water from fluoride-containing carbonated apatite surfaces, increasing the entropy gain and the intensity of electrostatic interactions between the mineral and protein surfaces. This mechanism may be important in studies with fluorapatite; however, it is not certain whether fluoride at the lower levels incorporated into fluorosed enamel results in a significantly more stable crystal lattice. A second possibility is that a linear decrease in the magnitude of the unit apatite cell with the addition of fluoride may result in a reduction of the volume of the unit cell when fluoride is incorporated (Moreno et al., 1974; Elliott, 1994). If the fluoride alters the packing of a unit apatite cell, it is possible that relatively more amelogenin binding sites will exist per surface area of apatite, thus explaining an increased amount of rh174 bound to fluoride-containing apatite. However, Elliott (1994) showed that there are no measurable changes in the unit cell parameters for enamel if fluoride content is 70–670 ppm (levels that would be found in fluorosed enamel). A third possibility is that there is a specific interaction between fluoride in the apatite crystals and amelogenin proteins. Kawaski and co-workers suggested that hydroxyapatite binds proteins through both calcium (positive) and phosphate (negative) sites on the surface (Kawasaki et al., 1986, 1987). We used fluoride in solution and also pre-treated the apatite crystals with fluoride to block positive charges on the apatite surfaces. At high fluoride concentrations, amelogenin binding to apatites was partially blocked. ITC showed that this could not be due to a direct interaction between fluoride and amelogenin, These results suggest that fluoride (high levels in solution) can block positively charged apatite surfaces, resulting in reduced amelogenin binding. Our studies showed that the effects of fluoride pre-treatment on amelogenin binding to surfaces are specific to apatites. When apatite crystals and their surrounding glass surface were pre-treated with fluoride, AFM imaging showed that amelogenin binding was specifically inhibited on the apatite crystal face, but not on the glass surface. It is likely that pre-treatment with the highly electronegative fluoride ion would block positive sites. Therefore, the decreased binding of rh174 to fluorapatite suggests a specific interaction between amelogenin and positive charges in the apatite crystal. Robinson and co-workers (Robinson et al., 2006) used AFM to show a decreased pKa of the surfaces of apatite crystals dissected from rats ingesting high levels of fluoride as compared with control rats, suggesting that more negatively charged proteins were retained on the apatite crystal surfaces of fluorosed tooth enamel. An explanation for these results could be that fluoride incorporation into apatite alters the overall surface charge of the apatite crystals, to result in a more positively charged surface. However, our results, showing only partial inhibition of protein binding after the pre-treatment of apatites with high fluoride levels, suggest that amelogenin binding to apatite is due to more than just positive charges on the apatite crystals. Other amelogenin/apatite interactions may include electrostatic interactions between positively charged groups in the protein and negatively charged groups on the apatite surface, as well as hydrophobic interactions and van der Waals forces. Clearly, further studies are needed, either to predict or to measure the effect of fluoride incorporation on apatite surface charge. It should also be noted that the recombinant amelogenin lacks a single phosphorylation of serine 16. The effect of this phosphorylated amino acid on amelogenin binding to apatite is not known. Altogether, these results suggest that a primary effect of fluoride incorporation into developing enamel mineral is to enhance binding of amelogenin to fluoride-containing apatite. It is possible that enhanced amelogenin binding to fluoride-containing carbonated apatite in enamel could delay enamel crystal growth during enamel formation, contributing to enamel fluorosis. Further investigations into the effects of fluoride incorporation on the surface charge of apatite crystals, including the formation of amorphous stages of apatite synthesis, are needed to improve our understanding of this interaction.
We acknowledge helpful discussions with Drs. Antonius Bronckers and Don Lyaruu, Vrije University and University of Amsterdam (The Netherlands), in the preparation of this manuscript. We are also grateful for support and advice from Dr. Kazuo Tanne, Hiroshima University (Japan). This research was supported by R01-DE015821 to W.L. and R01-DE013508 to P.D.B. from the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research, and by the Overseas Advanced Educational Research Practice Support Program of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, No. 16-325, Japan. We gratefully acknowledge Dr. Ewa Witkowska for the MALDI-TOF MS analysis of rh174, and Dr. Sally Marshall for x-ray diffraction analysis of the apatites.
A supplemental appendix to this article is published electronically only at http://jdr.iadrjournals.org/cgi/content/full/87/1/39/DC1. Received for publication December 22, 2006. Revision received September 14, 2007. Accepted for publication September 20, 2007.
Journal of Dental Research, Vol. 87, No. 1,
39-44 (2008) This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||





