| Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools. |
Clonal Persistence of Oral Fusobacterium nucleatum in Infancy
1 Anaerobe Reference Laboratory, National Public Health Institute (KTL), Helsinki, Finland; Correspondence: * corresponding author, gah{at}hi.is
Once established, early-colonizing bacterial species tend to persist in the mouth. To obtain detailed information on the population dynamics of early-colonizing oral anaerobes, we examined the clonal diversity and persistence of clones among oral Fusobacterium nucleatum populations during the first 2 yrs of life. Consecutive salivary samples from 12 infants, collected at 2, 6, 12, 18, and 24 mos of age, yielded a total of 546 F. nucleatum isolates for clonal typing with arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR). Up to 7 AP-PCR types were simultaneously detected in each sample. In 11 out of the 12 infants examined, AP-PCR types persisted for up to 1 yr. Strain turnover rate was high during the first year of life, but then the occurrence of persistent clones increased. This study indicates a wide genetic diversity within the species and provides evidence for the increasing persistence of F. nucleatum clones in the oral cavity with age.
Key Words: Fusobacterium nucleatum clonal diversity clonal persistence infants AP-PCR
Once established, early-colonizing bacterial species tend to persist in the mouth (Könönen et al., 1999b, 2002; Sarkonen et al., 2000). The clonal diversity among the pioneering commensals, such as facultative Streptococcus mitis and Streptococcus sanguis, and anaerobic Prevotella melaninogenica, is high, with many clones inhabiting the oral cavity simultaneously (Könönen et al., 1994; Hohwy et al., 2001; Pan et al., 2001). At the clonal level, the colonization pattern is rather unstable, especially during childhood. For instance, no persisting clones of S. mitis biovar 1 were detected in two infants examined, despite the high number of isolates tested, while persistent clones were frequent findings in their parents (Hohwy et al., 2001). In a longitudinal study on P. melaninogenica (Könönen, et al., 1994), 11 ribotypes were detected among 11 isolates from nine infants (mean age, 6 mos). Approximately 3 yrs later, 39 ribotypes were found among 96 isolates, but only 1 clonal type had persisted between these sampling occasions. To obtain more detailed information on the population dynamics of early-colonizing commensal anaerobes, we chose Fusobacterium nucleatum as a representative because of its steadily increasing frequency of detection in the oral cavity during the first years of life (Könönen et al., 1994, 1999b) and its crucial role in biofilm formation (Kolenbrander, 2000). On the one hand, it is assumed that this strictly anaerobic, Gram-negative species is capable of surviving in aerobic environments, because of its coaggregation with oxygen-consuming bacteria. On the other hand, its extensive coaggregation capability facilitates even more fastidious anaerobic species to colonize the oral cavity (Bradshaw et al., 1998; Diaz et al., 2002). After teeth erupt, the occurrence of F. nucleatum increases, probably due to a more suitable living environment created by gingival crevices, so that the species resides in all children at the age of 3 yrs (Könönen et al., 1994). The aims of the present investigation were, first, to examine the genetic diversity among developing F. nucleatum populations in the oral cavity and, second, to determine the turnover rate of oral F. nucleatum clones during the first 2 yrs of life.
Description of the Study Subjects and Specimens The present investigation included 12 infants who originated from a satellite subpopulation of the Finnish Otitis Media (FinOM) cohort study, where 50 healthy Caucasian infants, 2 mos old at baseline, were recruited to a prospective, longitudinal study on the development of the microflora in the upper respiratory tract and were followed for up to 2 yrs of age as described previously (Könönen et al., 1999b, 2002, 2003). At the time of study enrollment, parent(s) provided a written informed consent for all infants participating in the FinOM cohort study, and the Ethical Issues Committees of the National Public Health Institute, Tampere University Hospital, and Department of Social and Health Care of Tampere City, Finland, approved the study protocol. One specific target of the satellite study was to collect a minimum of 5 potential F. nucleatum isolates per infant on each sampling occasion, if available, from their unstimulated salivary samples at 5 scheduled visits at 2, 6, and 12 (± 2 wks) mos, and at 18 and 24 (± 4 wks) mos of age for clonal analysis. The specimen collection and culture of saliva have previously been described in detail (Könönen et al., 1999b). The isolates were stored at –70°C in vials containing 20% sterilized skim milk until revived for further testing. Twelve infants who were positive for F. nucleatum on at least 3 subsequent samplings and had the highest number of simultaneous isolates per sampling were chosen for the present investigation by clonal typing.
F. nucleatum Isolates
AP-PCR Typing
Statistical Analysis
AP-PCR Typing The AP-PCR patterns generally consisted of 2 to 5 major amplicons, but ranged up to 11 amplicons. The major amplicons and consistent minor bands of each isolate were visually inspected and compared with the amplification patterns of all other isolates from the same infant. When the isolates examined with the primers C1 and D8635 were found to be identical with one primer (usually C1), but dissimilar with the other, they were further investigated with use of the C2 and D11344 primers. In all those cases, the other primers also separated the isolates, which were regarded as belonging to distinct AP-PCR types.
The relationship between the total number of isolates from each sample examined and the number of AP-PCR types found among these isolates is represented in Fig. 1
Genetic Diversity of F. nucleatum Each infant harbored from 5 to 14 (mean = 8.3) different AP-PCR types during the first 2 yrs of life (Table). On average, 3.1 (maximum, 7) AP-PCR types could be found in one sample. As an example, Fig. 2
At each time, 1 (or 2) AP-PCR type was dominating the other types (Table). A single AP-PCR type accounted for 50% of the available isolates in 36 out of 45 samples (80%), and in the remaining 9 samples the dominant type represented at least one-third of the available isolates. An AP-PCR type was considered dominant if it accounted for more than one-third of the F. nucleatum isolates from each sample.
Persistence of F. nucleatum AP-PCR Types
In the present study, we demonstrated a wide genetic diversity within oral F. nucleatum populations intra-individually. Furthermore, many clonal types persisted in infants mouths for as long as 1 yr. The stability of AP-PCR types increased after the first year of life. AP-PCR typing is a simple, rapid, and reliable method for fingerprinting bacterial strains; however, its usage for F. nucleatum has thus far been limited (George et al., 1997; Avila-Campos et al., 1999; Moraes et al., 2002). We selected 4 out of 12 tested primers for AP-PCR typing of clinical F. nucleatum isolates, based on their discriminating AP-PCR patterns for different Fusobacterium strains (George et al., 1997; Narongwanichgarn et al., 2001). George et al.(1997) used pulsed-field gel electrophoresis to confirm their results revealed by AP-PCR typing with 2 primers (C1 and C2). To eliminate the need for further confirmation, we used 2 additional primers, both of which give greater resolving power than the C1 primer alone. The number of isolates available for clonal analysis is an important factor for viewing the actual clonal diversity within a sample. In general, the clonal variation seems to be high among oral early-colonizing commensals. The relationship between the number of F. nucleatum isolates examined and the number of AP-PCR types found indicates that when fewer than 10 isolates are examined, the number of AP-PCR types in the sample may be underestimated, whereas 20–25 isolates are likely to reveal the actual number of AP-PCR types present in the sample. This is in line with findings on S. mitis biovar 1 genotypes (Hohwy et al., 2001), where the clonal diversity is reflected in antigenic polymorphism displayed on the bacterial surface (Hohwy and Kilian, 1995). Early-colonizing commensals with wide antigenic variety seem to elicit natural immunity that is considered to be a benefit to the host (Smith et al., 1998). The clonal heterogeneity and frequent turnover of clones among oral F. nucleatum populations intra-individually allow the species to escape the host immune response, which is targeted against pathogens, and persistently to colonize the oral cavity. Analysis of our data on F. nucleatum revealed, in 11 out of 12 infants on subsequent sampling occasions, identical AP-PCR types, which could be stable for up to 1 yr. In contrast, no persistent genotypes of S. mitis biovar 1 could be detected in the two examined infants who, at the end of the 9- to 10-month follow-up period, were 19 and 15 months old (Hohwy et al., 2001). Although the emergence and disappearance of different genotypes could be due to mutations or genetic recombination, Hohwy et al.(2001) rejected that hypothesis in their recent study on S. mitis biovar 1. Similarly, the composition of F. nucleatum populations seems to be constantly changing; distinct AP-PCR types emerged and disappeared, and a high variability was seen in the proportions of persistent types throughout the sampling period. The dominating AP-PCR types were not more likely to be detected in the subsequent sampling than other types, nor were the persistent types more likely to be dominating in the next sample. Persistence of F. nucleatum AP-PCR types in saliva was occasional during the first year of life; however, persistent types became more frequent after 1 yr of age. Eruption of the primary dentition creates a new microbial habitat, the gingival crevice, which offers an optimal habitat for many anaerobic species colonizing the oral cavity. This improved living environment may explain the increased persistence of F. nucleatum clones with age. However, Suchett-Kaye et al.(1998) found no persisting ribotypes among 38 F. nucleatum isolates from eight adult dental students compared with 61 isolates collected 16 mos earlier. F. nucleatum is a heterogeneous species, and numerous AP-PCR profiles and high heterogeneity of serovars and ribotypes have been found within individuals (George et al., 1997; Thurnheer et al., 1999). Although generally considered to belong to the commensal oral microbiota, F. nucleatum presents some properties which are regarded as virulence factors: It is capable of binding to epithelial cells and invading them (Han et al., 2000), and of agglutinating and lysing erythrocytes (Gaetti-Jardim and Avila-Campos, 1999). In addition, some strains among F. nucleatum populations are capable of producing β-lactamases (Könönen et al., 1999a; Nyfors et al., 2003). Using AP-PCR and enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus PCR to type F. nucleatum from root canal infections in two patients, Moraes et al.(2002) found a single clone to be highly dominant in these infections, suggesting a difference in virulence for different clones of F. nucleatum. In children, F. nucleatum has been associated with infections in the head and neck area, especially in chronic otitis media (Brook et al., 2000). We did not investigate the virulence of F. nucleatum; however, some differences in the virulence potential between these clones may exist. F. nucleatum was the most common anaerobic finding in nasopharyngeal aspirates collected from these infants during acute otitis media (Könönen et al., 2003). Interestingly, the colonization of infants nasopharynges by anaerobes occurs exclusively during infection (Könönen et al., 2003), and then the colonizing strains seem to be of salivary origin (Haraldsson et al., 2004). The high intra-individual diversity among F. nucleatum populations found in the present study as well as in other studies (George et al., 1997; Thurnheer et al., 1999), in connection with infections caused by single clones, implies the pathogenic potential of the species to be of an opportunistic nature, with some clones potentially being more virulent than others. This investigation demonstrated a wide genetic diversity and frequent presence of persistent clones within oral F. nucleatum populations during the first 2 yrs of life. How closely related the clonal types of F. nucleatum are in this chronologically and geographically homogeneous study population remains to be shown.
The authors thank Jorma Torppa and Erkki Komulainen for statistical help. This investigation was financially supported by The Icelandic Research Fund for Graduate Students and The Centre for International Mobility (CIMO). The paper is based in part on an abstract presented at the 81st General Session of the IADR, Göteborg, Sweden, June, 2003. Received for publication August 19, 2003. Revision received March 8, 2004. Accepted for publication March 18, 2004.
Journal of Dental Research, Vol. 83, No. 6,
500-504 (2004) This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
2) test and by non-linear simple regression (curve-fitting). 

50% of the available isolates in 36 out of 45 samples (80%), and in the remaining 9 samples the dominant type represented at least one-third of the available isolates. An AP-PCR type was considered dominant if it accounted for more than one-third of the F. nucleatum isolates from each sample. 


